Pezzo dopo pezzo il quadro si completa. Tre ore fa il codice sorgente dell’app Immuni pubblicato su GitHub sotto licenza libera si arricchiva del backend. Scritto bene? Scritto male? È in grado di fare quello che ci hanno promesso? Il codice è là, a disposizione di chiunque voglia esaminarlo o, meglio ancora, dare una mano a migliorarlo.
I strongly share @gvdr’s concerns. The documentation alone, albeit undoubtedly a first step, is not enough any more: not with a release deadline for the executable app so close in time.
Making the code available as early in the process as possible (i.e., NOW), is sensible for two reasons:
- there do exist a legal requirement by art. 69 of the Italian Codice dell’Amministrazione Digitale, as well as mandatory compliance with the Guidelines published by AGID
- this is a legit case for open innovation: releasing the code is a good way of summoning the relevant communities both in Italy and abroad, which will be happy to provide suggestions and improvements not just on the wording of a few sentences in the documentation itself but on functional and non-functional requirements, design, code quality, privacy- and security-related vulnerabilities, inclusiveness and accessibility and so forth.
As Immuni ultimately amounts to a policy implementation, I expect transparency and openness to be pivotal. What the Italian government should not do in any case is to destroy mutual trust with all involved stakesholders.
|First published on||GitHub Issues|